Best Puppy Teething Toys for Sore Gums and Chewing
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Good puppy teething toys are soft enough for young gums, sized to your puppy’s weight, and easy to wash, and the listings in this guide differ most on those three points. This roundup compares eight puppy teething toys from their Amazon listings: four Nylabone rings and bones, three multi-pack rubber options, and one freezable water-filled pair. It sticks to what each listing states, flags where listings disagree, and marks missing details as not stated.
Quick answer
- Young puppy with gentle chewing: the Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Ring Bone (X-Small up to 15 lbs, Medium up to 35 lbs) and the Nylabone Puppy Pacifier (up to 25 lbs) are described as soft material for gentle chewers and are freezer-friendly in the ring-bone versions.
- Want a chilled toy: the Nylabone ring bones are listed as freezer-friendly, and the SPOFLY pair is built to be filled with water and frozen.
- Want variety in one purchase: the CGBD 6-pack, Hurray 3-pack and SQBG 5-pack all come as sets.
- Puppy with adult teeth or a strong chewer: the Nylabone Puppy Power Chew is the one listing that says it is intended for that stage. Supervise with any toy.
How to choose teething toys
Teething is a stage when puppies chew more. Product pages talk about soothing sore gums, but they do not give medical advice, and neither does this guide. If your puppy seems to be in pain, will not eat, or has bleeding or swollen gums, call your vet. For choosing a toy, the practical questions are below.
1. Match the toy to the puppy’s weight
Dog toy sizes are tied to weight on these listings. The Nylabone X-Small is for puppies up to 15 pounds, the Pacifier and the Small Power Chew for dogs up to 25 pounds, the Medium for up to 35 pounds, and the Hurray 3-pack for up to 18 lbs. The CGBD 6-pack and the SQBG listing say small dogs, and the CGBD page says it is not for large breeds. A toy that is too small for the mouth is a poor idea, so size up toward the listing’s range if your puppy is near the top of a weight band.
2. Look at the material
- Polyurethane (Nylabone ring bone and pacifier, per specs) is described as soft material for gentle chewers.
- Nylon (Nylabone Puppy Power Chew) is listed as a firmer, long-lasting material for stronger chewers or puppies with adult teeth.
- Natural rubber (CGBD, Hurray, SPOFLY, and SQBG with cotton rope) is described as non-toxic and BPA-free on some listings.
The rubber listings also describe textured bumps, which the sellers say clean teeth and massage gums. Those are seller descriptions; they are not a substitute for dental care from your vet.
3. Check for chill options
Two listings talk about cold. The Nylabone ring bones say they are freezable for extra-soothing relief, and the SPOFLY pair is sealed with pure water inside and can be frozen directly. A chilled toy is a popular approach, but follow each listing’s guidance on what to freeze and for how long.
4. Plan for supervision
Every toy can be chewed apart. The CGBD listing says to use it only under supervision if your dog is an extremely aggressive chewer, and not for large breeds. The Nylabone Puppy Chew listings say the soft material is not intended for powerful puppies or puppies with adult teeth. Watch your puppy, and take a toy away if pieces come off.
5. Think about cleaning
The Hurray listing says the toys clean easily with water. Others do not give a cleaning method. For anything without a stated method, rinse and let it dry, and replace worn toys.
Comparison table
| Toy | Material (specs) | Pack | Listed dog size | Item weight | Notable per listing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Ring Bone, X-Small | Polyurethane | 1 | Puppies up to 15 lbs | 1.28 oz | Freezer-friendly, chicken flavor, made in New Jersey |
| Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Ring Bone, Medium | Polyurethane | 1 | Puppies up to 35 lbs | 4 oz | Freezer-friendly, chicken flavor |
| Nylabone Puppy Pacifier | Polyurethane | 1 | Up to 25 lbs | 3.53 oz | Bacon flavor, 6 x 1.25 x 1.5 inches |
| Nylabone Puppy Power Chew Teething Rings, Small | Nylon | 1 | Up to 25 lbs | 3.18 oz | For power chewers or puppies with adult teeth |
| CGBD 6-Pack Soft Dental Toys | Natural rubber | 6 | Puppies and small dogs | 12.6 oz (set) | 6 shapes, molar bumps, supervise aggressive chewers |
| Hurray 3-Pack | Natural rubber | 3 | Up to 18 lbs | 5.65 oz (set) | 578 raised points, cleans with water |
| SQBG 5-Pack Rubber and Rope | Cotton and natural rubber | 5 | Small dogs | 0.22 kg (set) | Rings and balls, tug use |
| SPOFLY 2-Pack Freezable | Rubber, water-filled (per bullet) | 2 | All breed sizes (specs) | 0.32 kg (set) | Sealed, freeze directly, nontoxic and BPA-free |
The eight puppy teething toys
Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Ring Bone, X-Small: the tiny-puppy ring
This is the smallest Nylabone in the set, listed for puppies up to 15 pounds. The listing describes ridges and nubs that it says soothe sore gums while cleaning teeth, soft material for gentle chewers, and a chicken flavor infused throughout that may help reduce mouthing of household items. It is freezer-friendly, so you can chill it before use. It measures 6.9 by 3.6 by 0.7 inches, weighs 1.28 ounces and is made in New Jersey according to the listing.
It is not intended for powerful puppies or puppies with adult teeth. Best for: toy-breed puppies in the first months of chewing.
Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Ring Bone, Medium: the mid-size ring
The same design as the X-Small, scaled up for puppies up to 35 pounds. It measures 7.9 by 4.3 by 1 inches and weighs 4 ounces. The chicken flavor, freezer-friendly note and gentle-chewer warning all match the smaller version. Pick this one when the X-Small would be swallowed too easily by a bigger puppy’s mouth, and keep to the weight guidance.
Best for: medium-breed puppies who like a ring shape they can hold with their paws.
Nylabone Puppy Pacifier Chew Toy: the bacon-flavored nub toy
The pacifier shape has nubs the listing says comfort gums and help clean teeth, with bright colors and a bacon flavor. It is described as soft material for teething pups with gentle chewing styles, meant for dogs up to 25 pounds. The bullets give 6 by 1.25 by 1.5 inches, and the specs list 8.4 by 3.9 by 1.7 inches (likely package size) and 3.53 ounces. The specs also list uses including chewing, teething and training. Not intended for powerful puppies or puppies with adult teeth.
Best for: small puppies in the 25 pound range that like a shape with an easy handle.
Nylabone Puppy Power Chew Teething Rings, Small: the firmer nylon option
This is the one Nylabone here made for a different stage. The listing says it is intended for puppies who are more powerful chewers or who have their adult teeth, and the specs list nylon rather than polyurethane. The text calls it long lasting, bacon-flavored, and dental-textured to help reduce plaque and tartar as puppies chew. It is sized for dogs up to 25 pounds, measures 6 inches long out of the package, and weighs 3.18 ounces.
The listing does not mention freezing, and nylon chews are a firmer product, so do not assume it is gentle on very young gums. Best for: puppies that destroyed the softer toys, subject to supervision and your vet’s guidance.
CGBD 6-Pack Puppy Teething Chew Toys: the variety pack
Six shapes in one set, made from natural rubber that the listing calls 100% non-toxic and BPA-free. Molar bumps are described as massaging gums and cleaning teeth. The listing is clear about limits: it is for small dogs and puppies, not large breeds, and should be used under supervision when a dog is an extremely aggressive chewer. The set weighs 12.6 ounces and the specs give 7.5 by 1.9 by 7.5 inches.
It also suggests the toys can help with training and play outdoors. Best for: small-breed puppies, and for rotating toys so your puppy does not fixate on one.
Hurray 3-Pack Puppy Chew Toys: the pea-shaped trio
Three oblong rubber toys in red, blue and green with a polka dot pattern, listed for dogs up to 18 lbs. The listing says each has 360-degree molar-style points, 578 in total, and that the rubber is meant to be gentle on gums. It can be cleaned with water. The specs describe the material as natural rubber, list indoor and outdoor use, and say waterproof. Each item is about 4.72 by 1.97 by 1.38 inches and the three weigh 5.65 ounces. The listing’s flavor field says peanut butter while the scent field says unscented, so do not buy it for flavor.
The product description makes broad dental claims. Treat them as the seller’s wording and ask your vet about dental care. Best for: small puppies, especially if you want something you can wash easily.
SQBG 5-Pack Rubber and Rope Puppy Toys: the tug-and-chew set
Five toys combining rubber and cotton rope, in rings and balls, with a tug-of-war use listed in the specs. The listing is aimed at high-energy puppies and uses strong language like “indestructible” and “for aggressive chewers”. This guide does not repeat those promises. Rope can fray, and loose strands should not be swallowed, so supervise tug play and remove frayed pieces. The set weighs 0.22 kg and the specs list a green color, a small size and indoor or outdoor use. The warranty field says none.
Best for: an active small puppy where you will be playing along.
SPOFLY 2-Pack Freezable Teething Toys: the water-filled chillers
The SPOFLY pair is built around cold. The listing says the rubber is nontoxic and BPA-free with no strong rubber smell, sealed with pure water inside so it can be frozen directly with no refilling. The shapes include a dumbbell and a teething ring. The specs list all breed sizes, small dog size, indoor use, 7 by 6.6 by 2 inches and 0.32 kg for the pair. The warranty field reads lifetime. Only one bullet is given in the listing, so details beyond those are not stated.
Because the toy is sealed with water, check it for punctures before each use, and discard it if it leaks or a seam splits. Best for: puppies who like a cold surface on the gums.
Which toy for which puppy
- Tiny breed under 15 lbs: Nylabone X-Small ring, or the Hurray for up to 18 lbs.
- Small breed up to 25 lbs: Nylabone Pacifier, the CGBD set or the SQBG set.
- Medium breed up to 35 lbs: Nylabone Medium ring.
- Prefers cold: Nylabone ring bones or the SPOFLY pair.
- Chews hard or has adult teeth: Nylabone Puppy Power Chew, with supervision.
- Likes tug: SQBG, supervised.
Safety habits that matter more than the product
- Supervise. Several listings include this warning, and it applies to all of them.
- Inspect often. Toss toys that crack, shed pieces or fray.
- Do not freeze what is not meant to be frozen. Only the Nylabone ring bones and the SPOFLY pair say they can be.
- Rotate toys. The multi-packs make this easy.
- Do not rely on a toy for dental care. Ask your vet about teeth and gums, especially if something looks wrong.
- Respect the weight range. A toy sized for a 15-pound puppy can be a problem for a larger one.
Related reading
Our reviews of the Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Ring Bone and the Nylabone Puppy Pacifier go deeper on those two toys.
FAQ
When do puppies start teething?
The listings do not give ages. Ask your vet about your puppy’s timeline. The product pages here only describe the toys, which is why most tie size to weight rather than age.
Can I freeze puppy teething toys?
Only some. The Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Ring Bone listings call the toy freezer-friendly, and the SPOFLY pair is meant to be filled with water and frozen. The other listings do not say, so do not assume.
What size teething toy should I buy?
Go by your puppy’s weight and the listing’s range: up to 15 lbs for the X-Small ring, up to 18 lbs for the Hurray, up to 25 lbs for the Pacifier and the Small Power Chew, and up to 35 lbs for the Medium ring.
Are soft toys or firm toys better?
Soft toys are the stated choice for teething puppies with gentle chewing styles. The firm nylon option is described for stronger chewers or puppies with adult teeth. Your vet can help you choose when you are unsure.
Is rubber or nylon safer?
The listings do not rank them. Rubber sets say non-toxic and BPA-free, nylon is described as long lasting. What matters is supervision, the correct size and checking for wear.
My puppy chews furniture. Will a toy fix that?
The Nylabone ring bone listing says the flavor may help reduce mouthing of household items, and the Hurray listing says it redirects chewing away from furniture. Neither is a guarantee. Offer the toy when your puppy starts chewing the wrong thing and praise the right choice.
Bottom line
Choose by weight first, then by material: soft for young gentle chewers, firm nylon only when the puppy is clearly past the soft stage, and a multi-pack if you want variety. Supervise every session and ask your vet about anything that looks like pain.
