Puppy Chewing Everything Except Toys: Better Picks
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Details
Puppies chew whatever is nearby, from furniture legs to shoes. A puppy that ignores its toys may simply prefer a different texture or shape, so the easiest fix is to offer a few kinds and see which one it picks up. This guide compares six puppy chew toy sets for small puppies using only what each listing states.
Related reading: chews for dogs that chew everything but toys, safe chew toys for teething puppies and chew toys for Golden Retriever puppies. Every set here is listed for small or extra small dogs, so larger breeds should start with that last guide.
Quick answer
For the widest variety, the Zeaxuie 25 pack and the 20 packs from Beiker and the unbranded luxury set give you many shapes to test. Beiker says its 20 toys are all genuine toys with no poop bags counted, and it includes 6 soft rubber dental toys. For a single, soft chew for puppies up to 25 lbs, the Nylabone Puppy Pacifier is the simplest choice. Bag rolls and holders in some sets are not chew toys.
Product comparison
| Product | Pack | What is in it | Size wording |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beiker | 20 pack | Includes 6 soft rubber dental toys; no poop bags counted | Small breed |
| Zeaxuie | 25 pack | Rope, squeaky plush, rubber chew, treat ball, dog bag rolls and holder | Small |
| Luxury 20 pack (unbranded) | 20 pack | Cotton rope, treat ball, rubber toothbrush bone, tug toy, pacifier toy, teething rings | Small breed |
| Nylabone Puppy Pacifier | Single | Soft nubbed chew | Puppies up to 25 lbs |
| XIUGOAL pink | 9 pack | 3 squeaky plush, 3 rubber chew, 3 rope toys, extra dog bags | Extra small and small, under 25 lbs |
| 6 pack teething toys (unbranded) | 6 pack | Six shapes with massage points | Small |
The six sets in detail
Beiker 20 pack puppy chew toys
What it is: A 20-toy set for puppies and small dogs. The listing says it has no poop bags or other non-toy items inflating the count, and includes 6 soft rubber dental toys that it describes as softer and more elastic than traditional TPR toys. It carries a 1 year warranty and lists an item weight of 0.87 kg and a dimension of 5.1 inches.
Who it suits: Owners of a teething small-breed puppy who want to test many shapes at once.
Pros:
- All 20 items are toys, according to the listing
- Soft rubber toys for sore gums
- 1 year warranty
Cons:
- Small Breed wording with no weight range
Skip if: Your puppy is a medium or large breed.
View the Beiker set on Amazon (affiliate link)
Zeaxuie 25 pack puppy toys
What it is: A 25-piece set with rope toys, squeaky plush toys, rubber chew toys, a treat ball, dog bag rolls and a bag holder, listed for small puppies and for indoor and outdoor use. The listing says the rope toys have tight weaves and are made of natural material. Item weight is 1.5 pounds and a dimension of 5 inches is listed.
Who it suits: Owners who want the largest pack and do not mind that part of it is walking gear.
Pros:
- Largest pack in this guide
- Mix of rope, plush, rubber and a treat ball
Cons:
- The count includes bag rolls and a holder, which are not toys
Skip if: You want to count only real chew toys.
View the Zeaxuie set on Amazon (affiliate link)
Luxury 20 pack puppy teething toys
What it is: A 20-toy set for small breeds and puppies with cotton rope toys, a treat dispenser ball, a rubber toothbrush bone, a tug of war toy, a pacifier toy and teething rings. The listing says the rope toys and the rubber bone with soft spikes give gum massage. Item weight is 1.9 pounds.
Who it suits: Owners who want a mix of chewing, tugging and treat toys.
Pros:
- Named variety, including a treat ball and teething rings
- Listed for chewing, playing, teething and training
Cons:
- No brand shown and no weight range stated
Skip if: Your puppy is not small.
View the luxury 20 pack on Amazon (affiliate link)
Nylabone Puppy Pacifier chew toy
What it is: A single soft chew with nubs, made for teething puppies up to 25 lbs. The listing says the nubs comfort gums and help clean teeth. It adds that it is not intended for powerful puppies or puppies with adult teeth.
Who it suits: Owners of a gentle-chewing puppy who want one simple, soft toy.
Pros:
- Clear 25 lb limit
- Soft material for gentle chewers
Cons:
- Not for powerful chewers or adult teeth
- Only one toy
Skip if: Your puppy chews hard or is over 25 lbs.
View the Nylabone pacifier on Amazon (affiliate link)
XIUGOAL pink 9 pack
What it is: Nine pink toys for small dogs under 25 lbs: 3 squeaky plush toys, 3 rubber chew toys and 3 rope toys, plus extra dog bags. The listing says the elephant toy has no stuffing and makes squeaky and crinkle sounds. Breed wording is extra small and small.
Who it suits: Owners of an extra small puppy who like squeaky and crinkly toys.
Pros:
- Clear under 25 lbs wording
- Equal mix of plush, rubber and rope
- No-stuffing plush, per the listing
Cons:
- The pack also includes bags, which are not toys
Skip if: You want a set that is all chew toys.
View the XIUGOAL set on Amazon (affiliate link)
6 pack teething toys with massage points
What it is: Six chew toys in six shapes, each with massage points. The listing says they soothe teething puppies and help prevent periodontal disease, which is the maker’s claim. Breed wording is small and the use is listed as puppy.
Who it suits: Owners who want a small set to see what shape their puppy prefers before buying more.
Pros:
- Six different shapes
- Small pack, so there are fewer items to inspect
Cons:
- Material, dimensions and weight range are not stated
Skip if: You want the material confirmed first.
View the 6 pack on Amazon (affiliate link)
Buying checklist
- Check the size wording. Nylabone and XIUGOAL give 25 lbs; the rest say Small or Small Breed.
- Count the real toys. Some packs include bags or holders.
- Pick soft toys for sore teething gums and tougher ones as the puppy grows.
- Offer a few shapes: rope, rubber, plush and a treat ball.
- Supervise play and throw out any toy that cracks, softens or comes apart.
- Check size again as your puppy grows.
FAQ
Which puppy toy set has the most items?
The Zeaxuie 25 pack, but it includes dog bag rolls and a holder. Beiker and the unbranded luxury set have 20 toys each, and Beiker says all 20 are toys.
Which toy suits a puppy under 25 lbs?
The Nylabone Puppy Pacifier is listed for puppies up to 25 lbs, and the XIUGOAL set is listed for small dogs under 25 lbs. The other sets say Small or Small Breed without a weight.
Are these toys safe for strong chewers?
The Nylabone listing says it is not intended for powerful puppies or puppies with adult teeth. None of these listings promises that a toy is safe for every puppy, so supervise play and remove damaged toys.
Why does my puppy ignore toys and chew furniture?
Puppies chew most while teething and may prefer a different texture. Try soft rubber, rope and plush, redirect to a toy each time, and speak with your vet if you see signs of pain.
Can I use these for a bigger breed puppy?
All six are listed for small or extra small dogs, so they may be too small for a larger breed and could be a swallowing risk. Choose a toy sized for your puppy’s mouth.
Closing note
A variety set is an easy way to find what your puppy likes, while a single soft chew is enough for a gentle chewer. Whichever you pick, supervise sessions and replace damaged toys.
